Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (2024)

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (1)
The world's greatest cheesecake, I swear to god

I love cheese.

No, I mean I really love cheese.

As in, I always forgo dessert when we dine out if there's a cheeseplate on either the dessert or appetizer menu.

So imagine my excitement when the April topic for the Grow It Cook It Can It Cook It! 2012 challenge turned out to be fresh cheese. Yay! (I've really been enjoying that we're tackling some real cooking staples as part of this challenge, as opposed to getting all elaborate and complicated.)

As Caroline did, I decided to stick with fresh ricotta. I have made mozzarella in the past but the idea of making cheese in 10 minutes using only three ingredients was just too tempting.

Seriously. Ten minutes, three ingredients.

This was so easy there barely needs to be a recipe, so I'll just show you the steps (and I apologize in advance for the not-so-great step photos).

Step 1: Assemble the ingredients -- 1/2 gallon whole milk, 1/4 cup white vinegar, 1 teaspoon kosher or sea salt. (Yep, that's all.)

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (2)
Sorry, I left the salt out of the picture

Step 2: Heat the milk and salt to 180 degrees (use any kind of beverage or instant-read thermometer). This step only took a few minutes. You'll know you're close when the milk just starts to simmer.

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (3)
Heat the milk to 180 degrees

Step 3: When the milk hits 180 degrees, add the vinegar and stir for another minute or two. The milk will begin to separate into curds and whey right before your eyes, Miss Muffet!

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (4)
Slightly out of focus, but I think you can see the curds forming

Step 4: Pour the mixture into a colander lined with a few layers of cheesecloth and let drain (I let mine drain about 8 minutes or so, and it was pretty firm -- if you want it to be more spreadable, drain it a few minutes less, I'd say).

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (5)
It will still look runny when you first begin to drain it

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (6)
This is fully drained (about 8 minutes and pressed with the back of a spoon)

Step 5: Scrape the cheese (about 1 1/2 - 2 cups worth) off the cheesecloth.

VOILA! You just made ricotta!

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (7)
If you're just going to eat it on toast, I'd add a little salt at this point

Regular readers will remember that part of the challenge is not only to make the staple ingredient but also to use it in a recipe.

This is where I had a bit of a moral crisis.

(Over freakin' cheese? you may be thinking. Yes, sort of. Read on.)

Last week, I was telling my mother-in-law that the next challenge topic was cheese and that I was going to make ricotta but was still trying to decide what recipe to use to accompany it. She said, "I think there's a ricotta cheesecake you can make, but I don't have a recipe for it."

Um. Well, I do.

Well, actually, my mom does. For perhaps the greatest cheesecake on the planet. The cheesecake by which I compare all other cheesecakes. Trust me, I don't eat any other cheesecake anymore other than this one because none of them can compare.

Seriously. It's that good. (For criminey's sake, you can tell -- just look at it up there!!!)

So good, in fact, that I have never shared the recipe. I'm pretty protective of it. Selfish, even. Probably because it's my go-to ooh aah dessert. You know the one: you bring it to a party and everyone oohs and aahs. It's my secret weapon dish, the one that only I (well, and my mom) know how to make.

Until now.

I realized that it's silly and more than a little insecure of me to hoard this recipe. I mean, it's really not a secret family recipe. It came from some magazine in the 1970s (you know it's a 70s recipe because it calls for -- and my mom always added -- thick canned cherry pie filling as the topping. Shudder.). But my dad loved it. And if my dad loved it, it was a keeper.

So (and here I take a very deep breath), I'm officially crossing the line over into adulthood (as a 40-something) and sharing this recipe with you.

That's how much I love this blog, people.

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (8)

Trust me, you will like it. Scratch that: you will love it. It will ruin all other cheesecakes for you. It is thick and creamy and not-too-sweet and doesn't waste your time with any kind of crust. It's just cheese, cheese and cheese, oh yeah, with a side of cheese.

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (9)

I mean, it's called CHEESE CAKE for a reason, right?

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (10)
The top always looks unlovely and sometimes cracks but don't worry about either

But I'm telling you right now that if you invite me over for dinner and serve this cheesecake in my presence, I may mash it in your face. Because technically it will always be mine.

Well, my mom's.

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (11)

I've linked up this recipe at Momnivore's Dilemma Creative Juice Thursday and The Sweet Spot's Recipe Party

Super-Secret Ninja Family Recipe New York Cheesecake
(credit me or I will hunt you down, I swear it)

Note: The quantities below are for a 5-inch springform pan, because there's just me and Mr. Ninj. If you want to make the cake for a family or a dinner party, just double all the ingredients and cook it in a 10-inch springform pan.

Ingredients:
1 cup ricotta cheese, at room temperature (you, my friend, are all set because you just made your own!)
1 8-ounce package cream cheese, at room temperature
3/4 cup sugar
2 eggs
1/4 teaspoon lemon juice
1/4 teaspoon vanilla
1 1/2 tablespoons cornstarch
1 1/2 tablespoons flour
2 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
1 cup sour cream

Directions:
(Oh man, it is so hard for me to put this out there for the world to see...)

Blend ricotta and cream cheese well, then blend in the sugar. Beat in the eggs, one at a time. Add the vanilla, lemon juice, cornstarch, flour and melted butter and beat to combine. Fold in the sour cream and blend well.

Pour the mixture into a buttered springform pan. Place the pan IN A COLD OVEN and then turn the oven on to 325 degrees (Isn't this cool? No preheating!). Bake the cake for one hour. DO NOT OPEN THE OVEN DOOR. (Yes, this is in ALL CAPS and underlined on the recipe card my mom made for me.) After one hour, turn off the oven and leave the cake until cool, at least 2 more hours (leaving it in the oven overnight is fine as well).

Remove the sides of the springform pan and garnish the cake with fresh fruit -- or, frankly, with not a damned thing at all. It's that good.

Homemade ricotta and my super-secret family recipe New York cheesecake (2024)

FAQs

What is the difference between New York cheesecake and ricotta cheesecake? ›

Italian cheesecake is made with ricotta cheese instead of cream cheese. It's lighter and airier than traditional and New York-style cheesecakes.

How can I make my cheesecake firmer? ›

Starch makes the cheesecake more firm and sturdy, while a cheesecake that relies on eggs alone has a softer, super-creamy texture. I have tried both and love both.

Can I substitute cream cheese for ricotta? ›

Cream cheese: Cream cheese is made with milk and cream, while ricotta is made with just milk. The lower fat content makes the latter cheese slightly less creamy. However, cream cheese can still be substituted for ricotta.

Is ricotta cheese the same as sour cream? ›

Ricotta is a cheese with a similar thickness and mild flavor that can work well in the place of sour cream. If you're cooking, the fine texture of ricotta will melt right into a sauce or batter. It is not fermented like sour cream and won't lend quite the same subtle tanginess.

Can I use ricotta instead of cream cheese in a cheesecake? ›

Whether it's used in a cheesecake or a Danish, cream cheese brings a rich, decadent quality to sweet treats. But, it isn't the only type that works well in baked goods. Although it might sound unusual, ricotta cheese is an excellent substitute, too.

Is sour cream or heavy cream better for cheesecake? ›

Sour cream supports the underlying tang of the cream cheese, but, if overdone, it takes over as the dominant flavor. You need a little of each -- cream for texture and sour cream for flavor. With our ingredients settled, we focused in on how to keep the cheesecake from baking up grainy and cracked.

What does adding an extra egg to cheesecake do? ›

I also add an extra yolk, which enhances the cake's velvety texture. (Whites tend to lighten the cake, which is actually fine — if you don't feel like separating that fourth egg and don't mind some extra airiness in the texture, just add in the whole egg.)

What is the thickening agent in cheesecake? ›

Almost every cheesecake recipe calls either gelatin or beaten eggs, which are used as a setting or thickening agents. The cake will not set properly if there is no egg in the preparation, and you will just have a cream cheese pudding.

Why won't my cheesecake firm up? ›

Reasons To Why Your Cheesecake Is Not Setting
  • Incorrect Oven Temperature. One of the common reasons why your cheesecake doesn't set is because of the incorrect oven temperature. ...
  • Overmixing. ...
  • Incorrect Water Bath Method. ...
  • Let Your Ingredients Sit. ...
  • Check Your Pan. ...
  • Check For Doneness. ...
  • Allow The Cheesecake To Cool.
Sep 20, 2023

Why is my ricotta not creamy? ›

Whole Milk (not ultra pasteurized!): I recommend whole cow's milk for creamy flavor and texture. Alternatively, 2% or 1% milk can be used; but the final result will not be as creamy. Ultra pasteurized milk does not work for homemade ricotta. It won't curdle properly.

Which is better for you ricotta cheese or cream cheese? ›

Compared to most cheeses, ricotta is a healthier choice because it contains less salt and fat - 10 per cent fat, of which 6 per cent is saturated. It's light and creamy with a slightly grainy texture and delicate flavour that can be used on its own or in sweet and savoury dishes.

What cheese is closest to ricotta? ›

  1. Cottage Cheese. Cottage cheese is a good replacement for ricotta cheese in savory recipes. ...
  2. Cream Cheese. Cream cheese makes an especially good ricotta cheese replacement in many dessert recipes and sweet-tasting spreads. ...
  3. Mascarpone. ...
  4. Greek Yogurt. ...
  5. Queso Fresco. ...
  6. Sour Cream. ...
  7. Fresh Goat Cheese. ...
  8. Feta Cheese.
Mar 22, 2023

Can I use Miracle Whip instead of sour cream? ›

"I didn't have any sour cream so I added 2 or 3 tablespoons of miracle whip instead. It turned out very tasty.

What is a substitute for sour cream in cheesecake? ›

Yogurt is your best substitute for sour cream. Whether you're baking or making a dip or sauce, yogurt is a 1:1 sub. That means if your recipe calls for 1 cup of sour cream, you can replace it with 1 cup of yogurt. Full-fat Greek or natural yogurts work best, but low-fat or even nonfat can be used, too.

Is cottage cheese the same as ricotta? ›

They are both soft, white, fresh cheeses, but there are several differences that make each type of cheese unique. Texture: Ricotta cheese is made from very fine curds, resulting in a smooth but slightly grainy texture. Cottage cheese, on the other hand, contains more liquid and is lumpier than ricotta.

What's the difference between ricotta cheesecake and regular cheesecake? ›

The main difference between what we would consider typical New York American cheesecake and Italian cheesecake is that in Italy, cheesecake is made with ricotta rather than cream cheese. It is also a bit lighter and dryer, more cakelike and less cloying.

What makes NY style cheesecake different? ›

When it comes to New York style cheesecake, heavy cream or sour cream is added to the mixture to create a denser, smoother, and creamier cheesecake. A springform pan allows for even baking and a high temperature creates a nice, attractive golden brown crust.

What's the difference between New York style cheesecake and just regular cheesecake? ›

Regular cheesecake relies on heavy cream and sour cream to thin the batter and create a silkier, creamier texture. New York cheesecake is heavy on the cream cheese which is why it's so dense and rich. Extra cream cheese isn't the only thing that makes New York cheesecake so special.

What are the three types of cheesecake? ›

New York style cheesecake, classic cheesecake, and no bake cheesecake are the most popular types of cheesecakes, but the best cheesecake flavor is the one that you find irresistible — and that may be different for everyone.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Van Hayes

Last Updated:

Views: 6458

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Van Hayes

Birthday: 1994-06-07

Address: 2004 Kling Rapid, New Destiny, MT 64658-2367

Phone: +512425013758

Job: National Farming Director

Hobby: Reading, Polo, Genealogy, amateur radio, Scouting, Stand-up comedy, Cryptography

Introduction: My name is Van Hayes, I am a thankful, friendly, smiling, calm, powerful, fine, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.